A Critique and Analysis of Jurisprudential References to Verses 3 and 129 of Surah An-Nisa As to Justice Among Spouses

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Theology and Islamic Studies, Faculty of Hazrat-e Narjes, Vali-e-Asr University, Rafsanjan, Iran

10.30497/flj.2025.246697.2051

Abstract

Although the principle of justice among spouses is a mandatory obligation in the Islamic religion, its specific boundaries are subject to debate. Verses 3 and 129 of Surah An-Nisa, which address the issue of polygyny and justice among women, constitute a part of the Shia jurists' evidence on this matter. Given the fundamental role of the Quran as a source of Islamic law and the inadequacies of some jurists' arguments based on these verses, the present study employs a descriptive-analytical method to critique and analyze these references. The findings indicate that verse 3 emphasizes the necessity of providing mandatory alimony for all wives, while verse 129 prohibits disregarding women's emotional and sexual needs. Some jurists' arguments that verse 3 supports the desirability of equal distribution of alimony among wives or linking this verse to the obligation of equal division of nights are subject to criticism. Furthermore, the argument of some jurists that verse 129 does not necessitate equality in alimony or the right of nights, or even in heartfelt affection, is not acceptable.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Amily, Muhammad Ibn Makki, (1410 A.H.) AlLom’atol -Damshghiyyah – fi- feghhel-emamie . Beirut: Dar ol-Torath - Al-Darol-Islamiyya.
Amily, Zain al-Din bin Ali, (1413 AH) Masalikol-Afham- ela- tanghihe- sharaye’ol-  eslam . Qom: Islamic Al-Maarif Foundation.
Araki, Muhammad -Ali (1419 AH) Book of Marriage (Ketabol nekah) Qom: Nur Nagar
Askari, Hassan- ibn- Abdullah (1400 AH) al-Faroogh- fi -lLoghat. Beirut: Darol-Afaghel-Jadidah,
Ayatollahi, Zahra, (1379) "A Jurisprudential View of the Legal Provisions of Spouse Maintenance", Fiqh Magazine, (No. 23), 93-148 (In Persian)
Azhari -Heravi, Mohammad bin Ahmad (2001) Tahzeebol-Loghat. Beirut: Dare- Ehya’ol-Torathel--Arabi
Baghdadi (Mufid), Muhammad –ibn- Muhammad, (1413 AH) al-Moghne’e. Qom: World Congress of Hazara Sheikh Mufid - may God have mercy on him
 Bahrani, Hussain- bin –Muhammad( without date ) Anwarol- lavame’ – fi- sharhe  -Mafatihol  Sharaye’ Qom: Majma’ol- bohoothel -islami 
Emami, Mas’ud, (2012) "Regarding justice in polygamy “ Journal of  New search in  Islamic Jurisprudence, 20th year, number 4, (series 78), pp. 4-22 (In Persian)
Esfahani, Fadel -Hendi, (1416 AH) Kashful-letham -val -Ibham -An -Ghavaedel -Ahkam . Qom: Affiliated Islamic Publications Office to the community of teachers of Qom seminary
Farahidi, Khalil-ibn-Ahmad (1409-1410 AH) Al-eyn. Qom: Darol-Hijrat foundation.
 Fayyoumi, Ahmad bin Muhammad Moghri (without date ) al-Misbahol-Munir- Fi- Gharibol- Sharhel- Kabeer  lel-Rafe'i. Qom: Darol-Radi Publications.
Ha’eri, Seyyed –Ali- ibn- Muhammad -Tabatabayi (1418 AH), Riyadol-Masael- fi- tahghighol-Ahkam. Qom: Ahlol-Bayt Institute, peace be upon them
Haji Ali, Fariba; (2008), "The Jurisprudential and Legal Foundations of Polygamy in the Family" Journal of Fiqh and Family Law, Year 14, (Number 50), 109-131 (In Persian)     
Helli, Mighdad- ibn- Abdollah- Sayyuri (1425 AH), Kanzol- erfan- fi –feghhel- ghor’an. Qom: Mortazavi Publications
Helli, Mighdad-ibn-Abdollah- Siyuri (1404 AH ). Altanghihol- ra’e’- lemokhtasarel –sharaye’. Qom: Publications of Ayatollah Mar’ashi Najafi-  Library
Helli, Najm ol-Din- Ja’far- bin -Zahdari (1428 A.H.)   Izaho- taradodate alshara’e’. Qom: Publications of Ayatollah Murashi Najafi  Library
Holy Quran
Ibn -Abi -Hatam, Abd -Rahman ibn Muhammad (1419 AH) Tafsirol-Qur'anel -Azeem .Riyadh: Nizar- Mustafa -Elbaz Library
Ibn- Faris, Ahmad (1404 A.H.) Mo’jame  Maqhayisol  Loghat. Qom: School of  Ale’lamol- Islami
Ibn -Manzoor, Muhammad –Ibn- Mokarram (1414 AH)   . Lesanol-arab. Beirut: Dare- Sader
Ibn-Babivayh, Muhammad- ibn -Ali (1413 AH) Man –La- Yahdarahol -Faqih. Qom: Islamic publishing office affiliated with the community of teachers of Qom seminary
Jaziri, Abdol-Rahman; Gharavi, Seyyed- Muhammad, Mazeh, Yasser (1419 AH) Alfeghh -Alal- Madhahebel-arba’e- va- madhhabe – Ahlal-Bayt, peace be upon them; (Vol. 4) Beirut: Darol-thaghalin
Jurjani, AbulFath-ibn- Makhdoom (1362 AD) Ayatol- Ahkam .Tehran: Navid 
Kazemi, Fadel; Asadi, Javad-ibn- Sa’d (1413 AH) Masalekol-Afham- Ela – Ayatol-Ahkam. Qom: Alma’arefol- Eslamiyyah  Foundation.

Khomeini, Seyed Ruhollah Mousavi; (withouth date) Tahrir al-Usilah. Tehran: Imam Khomeini Editing and Publishing Institute
Koleyni, Muhammad-ibn- Ya’qoob (1429 AH) Kafi. Qom: Darol-Hadith .
Makarem Shirazi, Nasser (1371) .Nemune interpretation. Tehran: Islamic Bookstore. (In Persian)
Makarem Shirazi, Nasser (1386) One hundred and eighty questions andیشفث answers, Tehran: Darol -Kutub el-Islamiyyah. (In Persian)
Makarem -Shirazi, Nasser (1424 AH) ) Book of Marriage (Ketabol nekah)   Qom: Publications of Imam-  Ali- ibn- Abi- Talib (peace be upon him) school.
 Mesbahe -Yazdi, Mohammad -Taqi (2008) Ethics in the Qur'an. Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute  (In Persian)
Mousavi, Mohammad -Baqir (1374) translated by Tafsir al-Mizan. Qom: Society of Seminary Teachers, Islamic Publications Office. (In Persian)
Mughniyeh, Mohammad -Javad, (1421 AH) Alfiqhh- Alal -Mazahebel- -Khamsah. Beirut: Daro-Ttiarol - Jadid - Darol-Jawad, (In Persian)
Naraghi, Molla- Ahmed- ibn- Muhammad- Mahdi (1422 AH) Rasa’il -va -masa’il. Qom: Naraghein- Mulla- Mahdi –and- Mulla –Ahmad Congress  
Niazi, Ghodratollah ; Ramezani, Ali (2015) "Mearid –Of- Wife's- Maintenance" Journal of Fiqh and Family Law, Year 21, (No. 65) 131-147.
Qaderi, Mohammad Ali, (1400) "Jurisprudential research on oath issues", New Achievements in Humanities Studies, 4th year, (No. 42) 113-122. (In Persian)
Qureshi, Ali Akbar (1371-1372 AD) Quran Dictionary (ghamusol-ghor’an) Tehran :Dorol- Kotobol- Eslamiyyeh. (In Persian)
Ragheb- Esfahani, Hossein-ibn- Muhammad (1412 A.H.) Vocabulary of the words of the Qur'an. Beirut: Daro- Shamiah
Rouhani, Seyyed Sadiq (1412 AH), the jurisprudence of al-Sadiq, peace be upon him. Qom: Dar al-Kitab - School of Imam Sadiq, peace be upon him
Sadeghi Tehrani, Muhammad (1432 AH) al-Furqan- fi -tafsirel -quran –belqoran-  Val -sunnah. Qom: Islamic culture
Sadr, Seyyed Muhammad (1420 AH) Beyond Jurisprudence (mavara’ol- feghh) Beirut: Darol-Audva  lettabaah , alnashr , altozi’.
Shobeyri Zanjani, Seyyed Musa (1419 AH) Book of Marriage (Ketabol- Nekah) Qom: Rai Pardaz Research Institute
Siyuti, Abd- al-Rahman-ibn-Abi Bakr (1404 A.H.) Al-Dur- al-Manthur fi - Al-Tafsir  Belma’thur. Qom: Grand Ayatollah  Marashi Najafi.  Public Library
Tabari, Muhammad- ibn- Jarir (1412 A.H.) Jameol-Bayan- Fi -Tafsirel-Qur'an. Beirut: Darol-Ma’refat
Tabarsi, Fadl- ibn -Hasan (1372) Majma’ol-Bayan Fi Tafsirel-Qur'an. Tehran: Nasser Khosrow
Tabatabayi, Mohammad Hossein (1390 AH) al-Mizan fi Tafsirel-Qur'an. Beirut: Al-A’lami Publishing House.  .
Toreyhi, Fakhruddin- ibn- Muhammad (1375) (Majma’ol-Bahreyn) Tehran: Al-Mortazavi School
Trablesi, Ibn Baraj, Qadi, Abdul Aziz (1406 AH) al-Muhazab. Qom: Islamic Publications Office attached to the Society of Seminary Teachers.
Tusi, Muhammad- ibn-Hasan ( without date) Al-Tabyan- fi- Tafsirel-Qur'an. Beirut: Dar Ehya’ el-torathel-Arabi
Tusi, Muhammad-ibn-Hassan (1390 A.H.) Al-Istibsar- fimakh-Tolefa- minal-Akhbar. Tehran, Islamic bookstore.
Tusi, Muhammad-ibn-Hassan (1407 AH) Tahzeebol-Ahkam. Tehran: Darol-Kitabel-Islamiyat.
Tusi, Muhammad-ibn-Hassan, (1387 AH) Al-Mabusut- fi –feghhel- emamieh. 3rd edition, Tehran: Al-Mortazawi Library for the Revival of Al-Jaafari Antiquities
Yazdi- Tabatabai, Seyyed –Mohammad- Kazem ( 1409 AH) Al’orvatol- vothgha. Beyrut : Ala’lami lelmatbu’at institute
Yazdi, Muhammad (1415 AH) Fiqhhol-Qur'an, Qom: Isma’ilian Institute. (In Persian)