A Comparative Research on the Role of the Child's Interest in the Discharge of Child Adoption in the Iranian-British Legal System

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Refah University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Master's student in family law, Refah University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

In any community, children need to the protection, particularly when they are left without guardians or be abused with the poorly supervised. One of the supporting institutions is the adoption of children, entitled persons to adopt them. Child adoption at the level of formation and discharge has requirements and both levels are conducted considering the interests of the child. In this article, the factor of the child's interest in the discharge stage of child adoption, which is a quasi-family arrangement, is investigated. Child adoption is not the same in Iran and the United Kingdom and is different in the discharge stage. Hence, we have comparatively examined the discharge of Child Adoption in both legal systems in order to take advantage of foreign law to resolve the existing gaps, including the high interest of the child in the discharge of Child Adoption. In this article, using analytical, descriptive and library methods and based on comparative studies, the materials have been collected. The interest of the child is important both in jurisprudence and in the legal system of Iran but In Iran's legal system, the legislator has counted the cases of discharge of Child Adoption in the law, which makes the expediency to be considered less. This is while the interest of the child is important both in jurisprudence and in the Iranian legal system, but because in the Biritish system rights have not been counted, it is better to be the same in Iran. On the other hand, child adoption in the British legal system is indefeasible, but it is not absolute and in some special circumstances it can be terminated. Therefore, the termination of child adoption in the UK has not been defined and only the interest of the child is considered and any factor that threatens the interests of the child is in the circle of termination of child adoption. In the legal system of Iran, in order to ensure the high interest of the child, situations such as sexual abuse of the child, Illness, inappropriate performance, absence and misbehavior of adopted children, discrimination and injustice and anything that endangers their high interests considering the conditions of the child can be titled as the interest of the child in cases of discharge of adoption in order that the interests of the child are more likely to be preserved.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. Holly Quran.
  2.  

     

     

    • Abedini, A.; Meshkibaf, M. (2021). The Role of Interest in the Convention on the Rights of the Child and Iranian Family Laws. Comparative Research Journal of Islamic and Western Law, 8(4), 183-212.
    • Afsharghouchani, Z. (2021). The Issue of Inheritance in Adoption in English and American Law Compared to Iranian Law. Specialized Scientific Journal of Legal Encyclopedias, 4(10), 7-37.
    • Ahmadvand, K.; Azadmanesh, L. (2023). Examining the Financial Rights of Women and Men in the Light of Dynamic Jurisprudence. Jurisprudence and Family Law, 28(79), 295-327.
    • Arastouei, M. (2020). Nature, Effects, and Conditions of Adoption in Iranian Law with a Comparative View to Islamic Principles and English Law. Journal of Child Law, 2(6), 109-143.
    • Arastouei, M. (2020). Obligations of Parenting Couples Towards Adopted Children and Their Legal Consequences in Iranian Law Compared to English Law. Journal of Child Law, 2(8), 111-145.
    • Azari, H.; Mirahmadi, M. (2019). Judicial Approaches to Determining Interest in Child Marriage. Scientific-Research Journal of Women and Society, 10(40), 1-28.
    • Bashirtash, Sh.; Eftekhari Jahromi, G.; Safaei, S.H. (2020). Adoption in Light of Domestic Laws and Judicial Procedures in England. Journal of Private and Criminal Law Research, (33), 43-52.
    • Emami, A. (2000). Adoption in Current Iranian Law. Philosophical-Theological Researches, (3), 38-59.
    • Hamamloo, L. (2014). The rulings and effects of adoption in Islamic jurisprudence, Iranian law, and English law [Master’s Thesis, Imam Khomeini International University, Qazvin, Iran]. [In Persian]
    • Hashemi, S.H. (2015). Conceptualizing 'Interest' and Its Place in Family Law. Islamic Government Journal, 20(1), 127-154.
    • Hosseini Khaah, S.J. (2011). Ways to Reconcile Imamiyah Jurisprudence and International Human Rights in the Issue of Corporal Punishment of Children. Journal of Human Rights, 6(2), 1-18.
    • Imami, A. (2013). Mutalae Taqabi Nasb va Taghyeer Jensiat. Nashr Mizan.
    • Imami, A. (2013). Mutalae Taqabi Nasb va Taghyeer Jensiat. Nashr Mizan.
    • Islamic Republic of Iran. (1928). Civil Code. Hezar Rang Publications.
    • Islamic Republic of Iran. (1974). Law on the Protection of Orphaned Children.
    • Islamic Republic of Iran. (2012). Law on Family Support.
    • Islamic Republic of Iran. (2013). Law on the Protection of Orphaned and Neglected Children and Adolescents.
    • Jahandari, N. (2017). The nature and legal effects of the guarantee of obligations of guardian spouses [Master’s Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Bandar Abbas Branch, Faculty of Humanities, Department of Law]. [In Persian]
    • Katoozian, N. (2016). Civil law: Family law. Sharekat Sahami Enteshar.
    • Katouzian, N. (2016). Doreh Hoquq Madani Khanevadeh. Shirkate Sahami Enteshar.
    • Mithami, F.; Aghajanirouqi, A.; Shahbazi, A. (2020). The Best Interests of the Child in International Human Rights and Iranian Law: A Reflection on Practices and Theories. Comparative Legal Studies Journal, 24(2), 139-162.
    • Moghadadi, M.M. (2011). The Role and Impact of Interest in Child Custody from the Perspective of Jurisprudence and Law. Journal of Women's Cultural-Social Council, 14(54), 175-210.
    • Noor Ahmadi, A.; Rezvani Mofrad, A. (2022). Scope and Foundations of the Right to Education for Children with Disabilities in Jurisprudence, Law, and International Documents. Jurisprudence and Family Law, 27(77), 161-194.
    • Parsapur, M.B.; Nourbakhsh, S. (2015). Criteria for Assessing the Child's Best Interest in Imamiyah Jurisprudence, Iranian Law, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Comparative Research Journal of Islamic and Western Law, 2(3), 1-28.
    • Pirhayati, M.; Roshan, M. (2022). Examining the Jurisprudential Evidence of the Principle of Interest in Child Custody Based on Imamiyah Jurisprudence and Iranian Law. Family Research Journal, 19(73), 187-167.
    • Rostaminjafabadi, H. (2022). Exploring the Concept of Interest and Its Application in Religious Punishments with Reference to Islamic Penal Law. Studies in Jurisprudence and Islamic Law, 14(28), 75-102.
    • Sadr, S.M.; Arshadi, M.Y.; Badini, H.; Abbasi, S. (2014). Custody of Children in Jurisprudence and Iranian Law Compared to English Law. Journal of Civil Law Studies, 3(1),
    • Saeedi, A. (2018). A comparative study of adoption in Iranian and English law in light of the new Child and Adolescent Support Law ratified on 10/7/1392 [Master’s Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Shahre-Quds Branch, Tehran, Iran]. [In Persian]
    • Safai, H., & Imami, A. (2016). Mokhtasar Hoquq Khanevadeh. Mizan.
    • Sahib Jowahir, M.H.B. (1991). Jawahir al-Kalam (4th ed.). Nashr Ketabfurushi Islamiyeh.
    • Sahib Jowahir, M.H.B. (1991). Jawahir al-Kalam. Nashr Ketabfurushi Islamiyeh (4th ed).
    • Shariatinasab, S.; Sadeghi Moghadam, M.H. (2012). A Comparative Study of Maintenance in Adoption in Iranian and French Law. Journal of Comparative Law, (23), 139-160.
    • Soltania, A. (2016). Adoption in Iranian, French, and English law [Master’s Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Shahre-Quds Branch, Tehran, Iran]. [In Persian]
    • Supreme Court of Iran. (1981). Ruling No. 22, Row 60/8 of the General Assembly of the Supreme Court. https://ara.jri.ac.ir
    • United Nations. (1989). Convention on the Rights of the Child.
    • Yazdi, A.Q.B. (1996). Tarjomeh Shara'i (2nd ed.). Vol. 2. Nashr Daneshgah Tehran.
    • Zargushnasab, A.; Bagheri, P. (2019). Exploring Adoption in the Legal Systems of Islam, England, and America. Comparative Research Journal of Islamic and Western Law, 6(1), 57-86.

     

    منابع لاتین

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    • Adoption Act 1976 (c. 36(.
    • Carlson Solicitors. (2023). Child arrangements in the UK: Understanding the law. https://www.carlsonssolicitors.com/news-child-arrangements-in-the-uk-understanding-
    • Child Welfare Information Gateway. (2012). Adoption disruption and dissolution. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
    • Children Act 1989 (c. 41).
    • Children and Adoption Act 2002 (c. 38(.
    • European Commission. (n.d.). Best interests of the child (BIC). European Migration Network. https://home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/networks/european-migration-network-emn/emn-asylum-and-migration-glossary/glossary/best-interests-child-bic_en
    • Evans, A. E. (1934). Testamentary revocation by adoption of a child. Law Quarterly Review, 50, 486-490.
    • Gheera, M., & Jarrett, T. (2011). Parental responsibility. House of Commons Library.
    • Gilmore, S., & Glennon, L. (2016). Hayes and Williams' family law. Oxford University Press.
    • Herring, J., Probert, R., & Gilmore, S. (2015). Great debates in family law. Macmillan International Higher Education.
    • Howell, D. (2014). The Adoption and Children Act 2002: An overview. http://www.courtroomadvice.co.uk/
    • (n.d.). The principle of the best interest of the child. https://www.humanium.org/en/the-principle-of-the-best-interest-of-the-child/
    • Information Commissioner's Office. (n.d.). Children's code best interests framework. https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/childrens-code-hub/how-to-use-our-guidance-for-standard-one-best-interests-of-the-child/children-s-code-best-interests-framework/
    • The Transparency Project. (n.d.). Can an adoption order be undone? https://transparencyproject.org.uk/can-an-adoption-order-be-undone
    • Thomson Reuters Practical Law. (n.d.). UK legal resources. https://uk.practicallaw.thomsonreuters.com