The Standard and New Emerging Families in Iran and USA Legal Systems

Document Type : Scholarly Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Jurisprudence, Imam Sadiq university, Tehran, Iran

2 MA student of Family Law in Imam Sadiq University,Tehran,Iran

3 Assistant Professor Imam Sadiq university, Tehran,Iran

Abstract

The family has a unique meaning at different times, which has sometimes changed and evolved over time. Therefore, explaining the structure and concept of standard family and new emerging families, as well as families that deviate from the standard, is very important. The emergence of families with different structures such as cohabitation, same-sex family, self-marriage, object marriage, animal marriage, as well as single-parent families, which referred to as new emerging and unusual families, is one of the family challenges in today’s world. The studies show that there is no comprehensive definition, which explains the desired Iranian Islamic family in the Iranian legal system and this vacancy has been led to the confiscation of this structure for the intended purposes. The present article intends to examine the structure and concept of standard family with a statistical approach in Iran and the United States of America legal systems, to explain the structure, concept and examples of new emerging families, especially in the United States. This research is library-documentary in terms of method and fundamental-applied in terms of purpose. The findings of this study showed that there is a serious gap in explaining the standard family in Iranian law. In the discussions of Islamic jurisprudence and significant guidelines of Supreme Leader, many components have been introduced for the standard family in terms of the principles governing the family, but these components have no place in the upstream documents and Iran executive laws.  On the other hand, although all American family laws, both at the federal and state levels, have a high volume in terms of quantity, but in terms of content, they are with a humanistic approach and without considering human values. The same-sex family and other new emerging families are recognized in the laws of many US states and their members have legal rights.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  •  

    • AzimZadeh Ardebili, F. (1386). Mabani Hosne Moashaerat be Maroof dar Nezam Hoghooghi Khanevadeh az Manzr Ghoran Karim. Nashrieh Nedaie Sadegh, 48, 1-23.
    • AzimZadeh Ardebili, F. and Zabihi Bidgoli, A. (1396). Mabani Hoghoghe Khanevadeh da Eslam va Gharb. Tehran, Daneshgah Emam Sadegh.
    • Azizi, M. and Hosseini S. H. (1396). Tahlil ZarfiatHaye Saiasat Gozari Nahad Khanevadeh dar Iran baraye Gostaresh Ashkal Mashrooe Khanevadeh. Majaleh Motaleat Ejtemai Iran, 11(3), 104-125.
    • Brake, E. (2018). Do Subversive Weddings Challenge Amatonormativity? Polyamorous Weddings and Romantic Love Ideals. Analize-Journal of Gender and Feminist Studies. 11(3), 61-84.
    • California Legislative Information (2013-2014). Senate Bill No. 1306- Chapter 82. Retrieved from https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/ 306, Accessed 10 May 2022.
    • California Legislative Information (2019 March 25). CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE.Senate Bill No. 135. Retrieved from https://leginfo. ca.gov/, Accessed 14 May 2022.
    • California Legislative Information (2022). 2021 California Family Code. Retrieved from https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/, Accessed 10 May 2022.
    • California State Legislature. 2022. Laws and Constitutions. Retrieved from http://www.legislature.ca.gov/laws_and_constitution.html, Accessed 10 May 2022.
    • Chelbi, M. (1375). Jamehshaenasie Nazm. Tehran, Nashre Nei.
    • Dashti Khoydaki, F., Tabatabi, S. A. and EtemadiFar, A. (1396). Vazayef Zan dar Khanevadeh dar Fegh Emamiyeh. Avalin Hamayesh Melli Oloom Ejtemai, Oloom Tarbiati, RavanShenasi va Amniat Ejtemai. 7 Ordibehesht 1396, Karaj, pp. 1-10.
    • Dehghan, J. (1398). Baresi Jaygah HamBashi dar Nezam Hoghooghi Iran. PayanNameh Karshenasi Arshad Hoghogh Daneshgah Tehran.
    • Farhadi Ajorloo, S., Mojtahed Soleimani, A. and Khazaee, S. A. (1399). HamanandSazi Masaleh Keramat Ensan dar Fegh va Hoghoogh Mozooeh Iran ba Negah Ghorani. Faslnameh Ghaoran va Teb, 5(3), 131-140.
    • Florida Department of State (2016). The Constitution of the State of Florida. Retrieved from https://files.floridados.gov/media/693801/florida-constitution. pdf, Accessed 2022, April 28.
    • Ghanoon Asasi Jomhorri Eslami Iran (1368).
    • Ghanoon Eslahe Ghavanini Tanzim Jamiat va Khanevadeh (1392).
    • Ghanoon Hemayat az Khanevadeh va Javani Jamiat (1400).
    • Ghanoon Hemayat Khanevadeh (1346).
    • Ghanoon Hemayat Khanevadeh (1353).
    • Ghanoon Hemayat Khanevadeh (1391).
    • Ghanoon Madani (1394).
    • Ghanoon Tanzim Khanevadeh va Jamiat (1372).
    • Greene, A. (2010. April 12). 10 Romances between People and…Things. Woman’s day. https://www.womansday.com/relationships/a1464/.
    • Hemati HajiPirloo, F. and Momen, R. S. (1400). Motaleh Tatbighi nahadHaye jaygozin Ezdevag Daemi dar Hoghoogh Iran va America. DoFaslnameh Fegh Va Hoghoogh Khanevadeh, 26(74), 85-115.
    • Holoyda, B. J. (2022). Bestiality Law in the United States: Evolving Legislation with Scientific Limitations. Animals, 12, 1525, https://doi.org/10.3390/
    • Hooshyari, J., Naghibian, H. and Sedighi, S. A. (1399). Osool Hakem bar Ravabet Khanevadegi Nazer be Tahaghoghe Sabke Zendegi Eslami. Dovaomin Hamayesh Melli RavanShenasi va Salamt ba Mehvariat Sabke Zendegi, 20 Aban 1399, Shiraz, pp. 114.
    • Hore Ameli, M. B. H. (1409Gh). Vasael Alshiah. Ghom, Moaseseh Al-ol- Bayt Alayhem-o-Salam.
    • Jafari, E. (1396). Taghire Mafhoome Khanevadeh HamBashi ta HamgensGerai; Ba Negahi bar Sabke Zendegi, AsibHa va ChaleshHa. Faslnameh Motaleatie Sianat az Hoghooghe Zanan. 3(8), 137-165.
    • Johonson, S. M., Giuiano, T. A., Herselman, J. R. & Hutzler, K. T. (2015). Development of a brief measure of attitudes towards polyamory. Psychology & Sexuality, 6(4), 1-15.
    • Kalhor, M. and Arhami, A. (1392). Arzyabie Tatbighi SiastHaye Jomhoori Eslami Iran ba RRavandHaye Jahani dar Hozehe Khanevadeh. Motaleate Rahbordi, 15(59), 59-104.
    • Katoozian, N. (1394). Ghanoon Madani dar Nazme Hoghooghi Konooni. Tehran, Nashre Mizan.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1373). Sokhanan dar Khotbeh Aghd. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayat-o-Allah Al-Ozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/2/28 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1375). Sokhanan dar Ejtemae Zanan Khoozestan. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayatollah Alozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/1/16 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1379). Sokhanan dar Khotbeh Aghd. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayatollah Alozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/2/28 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1381). Sokhanan dar Khotbeh Aghd. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayatollah Alozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/2/28 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1383). Sokhanan dar Didar Jami az Mohandesan. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayatollah Alozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/21/13 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Khamenei , S. A. (1384). Sokhanan dar Didar Aghshare Mokhtalef Mardom. Bargerefete az Paygah EtelaResani Daftar Hefz va Nashre Asare Hazrat Ayatollah Alozma Khamenei. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/2/13 az https://farsi.khamenei.ir/.
    • Lytton, C. 2017. September 20. I me wed: why are more women choosing to marry themselves?, The Telegraph.
    • Mahdavi, M. (1395). Asle Keramat Ensani va Gofteman Nezame Zan va Khanevadeh. Hamayesh AmoozehHaye Eslami, Ensan Moaser va Nezame Khanevadeh, 19 Esfand 1395, Sari, pp. 1-14.
    • Mahdavi Kani, S. (1388). Sakhtare GozareHaye Akhlaghi Ghoran. Tehran, Daneshgah Emam Sadegh.
    • Mahdavi Kani, S. (1392). Osoole Hakem bar Ravabet Azaye Khanevadeh dar Nezame Marefati Eslam. DoFaslnameh Fegh va Hoghoogh Khanevadeh, 18(58), 1-28.
    • Majlesi, M. B.M.T. (1403Gh).Bahar Alanvar. Beiroot, Dar Ehya Altras Alarabi.
    • Makarem Shirazi, N. (1424Gh). Ketab Alnekah. Jeld 6, Ghom, Entesharat Madresh Ali Ben AbiTaleb.
    • Markaz PajooheshHaye Majles Shoraye Eslami (1382). CheshmAndaz Jomhoori Eslami Iran dar Ofogh 1404 Hejri Shamsi. Bazyabi Shodeh dar 1401/2/27, az https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/law/show/132295.
    • Moavenat Hoghooghi Riasat Jomhoori (1397). Majmooeh Tanghihi Ghanoon Hemayat Khanevadeh. Tehran, Moavenat Tadvin, Tanghih va Enteshar Ghavanin va Mogharart.
    • Motahari, M. (1380) Majmooeh Asar Shahid Motahari. Tehran, Entesharat Sadra.
    • Motschenbacher, H. (2014). Focusing on Normative in Language and Sexuality Studies Insights from Conversations of Objectophilia. Critical Discourse Studies, 11 (1), 49-70.
    • Nazari, I. (1386). Moghararate Marboot be Khanevadeh dar Ghanoon Madani Iran. Nashrieh Nedaye Sadegh, 12(47), 1-20.
    • Nemati PirLoo, D., Kardavani, R. and Vakili, M. (1390). Molazemeh Takalif Zojein va AkhlaghMadari dar Khanevadeh dat Manabeh Eslami. Faslnameh Shoraye Farhangi- Ejtemai Zanan va Khanevadeh, 14(54), 211-253.
    • Nosrati, A., Hosseini Zeidi, S. A. and Lashani, M. (1400). Ezdevaj Sefid az Manzre Feghi- Hoghooghi. Motaleat Rahbordi Zanan, 23(91), 89-106.
    • OECD Family Database (2021). Children in households by employment status. Retrieved from https://www.oecd.org/els/family/database.htm, Accessed 17 April 2022.
    • Parsa, F., Rostami, S. and Sajjadi, S. (1395).Vazayef Zan dar Zendegi Moshtarak va Nagshe on dar Ostovar Sakhtan Bonyad Khanevadeh az Didgah Feghe Eslami . Majaleh Moshavereh va RavanDarmani Khanevedeh. 26(22), 165-188.
    • Paygah EtelaResani Magham Moazam Rahbari (1395). Siasathaye Kolli Khanevadeh. Bazyabi shodeh dar 1401/2/25 Az https://www.leader.ir/fa/content/16173.
    • Porter, J. A. (2015). L’Amour for Four: Polygyny, Polyamory and the State’s Compelling Economic Interest in Normative Monogamy. Emory Law Journal, 64(6), 2093-2139.
    • Roshani, S., Gharavi Naini, N. and Bastani, S. (1394). Tajrobeh Ehsas Aramesh dar Zendegi Zanashooi: Motalehi Keifi ba Rooykared Nazarieh Mbnai. Nashrieh Motaleat Zan va Khanevadeh. 3(2), 61-89.
    • Sadr Tabatabi, F. (1380) Tadif Khanevadeh az Manzar Ghoran. Nashrieh PajooheshHaye Ghorani, 27-28, 68-81.
    • Safari, N. (1398). Negahi be Abad Hoghooghi Taghir Shekl Sakhtar Khanevadeh dar Hoghoogh Iran. Faslnameh Nameh Sadiigh, 2(3), 19-24.
    • Salehi Amiri, S. R. (1391) AndishaeHaye Rahbordi Zan va Khanevadeh. Tehran, Payam Edalat.
    • Sedighi, M. (1378). Negahi be Ravand Jahani Jonbesh Zanan va Mogheiat Zan dar Jomhoori Eslami Iran. Ketab Naghd, 3(3), 68-81.
    • Shoraye Alli Enghelab Farhangi (1384). Ghanoon Ahdaf va Osool Tashkil Khanevadeh va SiasatHaye Tahkim va Tali. Mosavabeh Shomreh 1414, Bazyabi Shodeh az https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/law/show/101204.
    • Shoraye Alli Enghelab Farhangi (1384). Naghsheh Mohandesi Farhangi Keshvar, Bazyabi Shodeh az https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/law/.
    • Texas Legislative Council (2022). Texas Constitution Include Amendments Through the November 2, 2021, Constitutional Amendment Election. 1st Legal Division of the Texas Legislative, Retrieved from https://tlc.texas.gov/ docs/legref/TxConst.pdf, Accessed 2022, May 14.
    • Texas Legislature Online (2022). Texas Current Statutes through the 87th 3rd Called Legislative Session 2021 (Family Code). Retrieved from https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/, Accessed 2022, May 14.
    • The California State Legislature .2019-2020. The Constitutions of California and the United States with Related Documents. 2019–20 Ed. Retrieved from https://www.senate.ca.gov/sites/, Accessed 2022, May 3.
    • The Florida Senate (2016). BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT SB 498. Retrieved https://www.flsenate.gov/ Session/Bill/ 2016/498/Analyses/2016s0498.ju.PDF, Accessed 2022, May 08.
    • The Florida Senate (2021a). 2021 Florida Statutes (Including 2021B Session). Chapter 741- Section 212, Retrieved https://www.flsenate.gov /Laws/ Statutes/ 2021/0741.212, Accessed 2022, May 06.
    • The Florida Senate (2021b). 2021 Florida Statutes (Including 2021B Session). Chapter 414- Section 0252. Retrieved https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/ Statutes/2021/414.0252, Accessed 2022, May 06.
    • S. Census Bureau (2022a). National Single parent Day: March 21, 2022 - . Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/data/tables/, Accessed 2022, April 15.
    • S. Census Bureau (2022b). State Population by Characteristics: 2020-2021 Current Population Survey (CPS). Retrieved from https://www.census.gov/ newsroom/stories/single-parent-day.html, Accessed 2022, November 16.
    • S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2022. The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2016/2017 Report of Sexual Violence. Recieved from: https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/nisvs/nisvsReportonSexualViolence.pdf, Accessed 2022, November 16.
    • S. Department of Health and Human Services . 2012. National Health Statistics Reports, 49. Recieved from: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr049.pdf.
    • S. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. 2018. The National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2015 Data Brief – Updated Release. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA. Recieved from: https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/2015data-brief 508.pdf.
    • S. National Center for Lesbian Rights (2017). Marriage, Domestic Partnerships, and Civil Unions: Same-Sex Couples within the United States. Retrieved from https://www.nclrights.org/.
    • United States Code (2022). Title 5- Government Organization and Employees. The Code of Laws of the United States of America, Retrieved from https://uscode. gov/ download/download.shtml, Accessed 2022, May 03.
    • United States Senate (2022). The Constitution of the United States of America. Publication 103-21, Retrieved from https://www.senate. gov/civics/ resources/ pdf/US_Constitution-Senate_Publication_ 103-21.pdf, Accessed 2022, May 06.
    • Yazdani, A. A. and Doosti, S. (1396). Ashkale NoPadide Khanevadeh dar Iran va ChaleshHaye On. PajooheshNameh MadadKari Ejtemai, 2(6), 75-101.